10 Reviews: Best Waterproof Mascara for Watery Eyes (Apr 2024)

Maybelline New York Sky High Mascara gives you maximum volume and length. From root to tip, the exclusive flex tower mascara brush bends to volumize and stretch every single lash. This Maybelline volumizing and extending mascara also contains bamboo extract and fibers for long, thick lashes that never feel weighted down. Maybelline mascara has undergone allergy testing and has been approved by an ophthalmologist as suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens users.

"This mascara is my new favorite mascara! For the price and the volume it is amazing!"

by d

With no flaking, smearing, or clumping, the L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Lash Paradise Waterproof Mascara delivers a feathery soft full lash fringe. With the voluminous mascaras, smudge resistant eyeliner, brow definition, and eye shadow palettes with tones for every eye color, you can create the ideal eye makeup look. The bristle brush’s unique form also has over 200 bristles for maximum coverage.

"Excellent product. I have serious eye issues not only with my eyes, but my eyelids. I have gone without mascara for a long time, but decided to give this a try. One of my eyes appears smaller, from surgery, and I have to apply more mascara to that eye to make it look more even to the other eye"

by DolliNana

The Disney Princess range by Essence Cosmetics is a limited-edition mascara that is very gorgeous! Each individual lash is sculpted with a cone-shaped fiber brush for added volume and definition. The sauce is velvety smooth with no globs or clots. It lasts all day and doesn’t fade, flake, or smear. This mascara is also PETA-approved, so you can feel good wearing it!

"Love this mascara, makes what little lashes I have look amazing."

by angie lyman

Pacifica Beauty’s mascara contains natural ingredients such as coconut oil, kelp extract, and vitamin B. These ingredients will moisturize, strengthen, lengthen, and volumize your lashes. Furthermore, the vegan brush is ultra-soft and separates each lash for a voluminous look. The mascara’s mild nature makes it a great choice for individuals with sensitive eyes & watery eyes.

"I was surprised at how good this mascara was. It stays on all day, no flaking or smudging at all. Washes off immediately with warm water and regular face wash. The color is shiny black, not dull gray like some. It looks fresh all day."

by J&M

Bestidy Twinkle Starlight Long Curl Mascara quickly adds volume and length to your lashes, resulting in defined and voluminous lashes with only one application. Moreover, the creamy, silky mascara glides over all lashes without clumping, flaking, or drying out. The hypoallergenic 4D silk fiber lash mascara also contains soothing components that are safe and pleasant for sensitive eyes, contact lens users, and watery eyes.

"My eyes are really sensitive to mascara so it’s hard for me to find one I like. I love this mascara!!! It doesn’t irritate my eyes and it comes off easily when I use makeup remover."

by The Pink Witch

For up to 18 hours, Maybelline Volum’s Express Colossal Mascara offers you a clump-free, bold, open-eyed appearance. Comes includes a giant brush and 2x the collagen-infused product for an all-day bold appearance that won’t clump. The big shot brush also has unique, wavy bristles that cradle lashes and the collagen formula add dramatic volume; it’s ophthalmologist-tested and acceptable for contact lens users and watery eyes.

"I've been wearing this mascara for years. The classic black works better than the glam black. The glam black doesn't seem to give you the volume that the classic black does. Really nice mascara."

by No name

Covergirl Lash Blast Volume Mascara is a volumizing mascara that quickly adds 10 times more volume to your lashes. This volumizing mascara covers each lash evenly and doesn’t clump or flake. Moreover, this mascara comes in four distinct colors, allowing you to select how aggressive you want to go. Furthermore, this mascara is ideal for individuals with watery eyes who want to achieve a dramatic lash effect.

"This mascara works well and doesn't irritate my eyes."

by Kelli Snow

COVERGIRL Lash Blast Clean Mascara adds 10 times the volume of bare lashes while the applicator brush separates and defines lashes for a longer-lasting effect. This lash-loving vegan mascara is infused with argan and marula oils and is designed without parabens, sulfates, talc, or mineral oil. It is smudge-proof, clump-proof, and wear-proof. As a result of the high quality components used in this mascara, it is appropriate for individuals who suffer from watery eyes.

"There is a big difference between this and my previous mascara. There is virtually no residue after washing this off. No racoon eyes! It felt very light yet it gave my lashes good volume. Definitely recommend."

by Michelle Clapps

Maybelline Great Lash Mascara is a lash-doubling formula that glides on smoothly and compliments any eye color. With a wide range of pencil and liquid eyeliners, highly pigmented eyeshadows, classic mascara, and eyebrow makeup, this Maybelline helps create looks that pull eyes, whether natural or dramatic. Furthermore, the hypoallergenic recipe has been approved by an ophthalmologist and is suitable for contact lens users.

"This is the best waterproof mascara I have ever used! I'm fair and buy the brownish-black. I never have to worry about smudges or getting caught in the rain. Builds and lengthens. Face cream takes it off with a washcloth or pad. No use for for expensive mascaras. Give it a go!"

by Lynette

The Drama Llama waterproof mascara is one of the best mascaras for sensitive eyes because it doesn’t contain GMOs, cruelty, preservatives, or gluten and is made from high-quality vegan ingredients. This mascara also stays on for a long time, doesn’t smudge, and makes your natural lashes look longer and thicker. Second, this mascara comes in a small size that makes it easy to carry with you.

"This mascara is amazing! Long-wearing no smudge and made my natural lashes look so much longer and thicker! Definitely a great product. Going to buy a couple more for stocking stuffers."

by Tiffany B.