10 Reviews: Best Waterproof Mascara for Sensitive Eyes (May 2022)
Shop these 10 finest waterproof mascara for sensitive eyes, and get your better make up look whenever and wherever you go!
by Rahmania Yunita · updated on · price $5.00 - $26.00 · 6 views
We hope you love the shops and products we recommend! Just so you know, our site may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and products in stock as of time of publication.
Maybelline New York
|Product Name||Mile High Club Black Mascara||High Impact Waterproof Mascara||Lash Blast Volume Mascara||Lash Effect Mascara||Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara||Healthy Lengths Mascara||Age Perfect Lash Magnifying Mascara||Professional Curved Brush Mascara||Toleriane Extension Mascara||Waterproof Mascara|
|Features||Intensely saturates lashes||Instant volume and length||Mega volume in an instant||Lasts all day||Advanced thickening formula||Safe for sensitive eyes||Volumizing formula||Lengthen & define lashes without flaking||Visibly longer lashes||Enhance long & thicker lashes|
|COLOR||Black||Brown, Black||Black||Black||Black||Black||Black||Black, Brown||Black||Black|
|VOLUME||0.35 oz||8 ml||0.44 oz||n / a||24 ml||6.2 ml||0.28 oz||9 ml||0.76 oz||8 ml|
|BENEFITS||Lengthening, thickening, etc||Lengthening||Volume-boosting||Dramatic volume||Full healthy-looking lashes||Look 100% longer||Hydrating||Defining, volumizing, lengthening||Visibly longer lashes||No smudge, longer & thicker lashes|
|Buy at||view product on Wander Beauty view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on Clinique view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on Covergirl view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on Essence Cosmetics view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on Maybelline view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on Neutrogena view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on L'Oreal Paris view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on CoverGirl view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on La Roche-Posay view product on Amazon view product on eBay||view product on Drama Llama view product on Amazon view product on eBay|
Whoever has sensitive eyes understands that selecting the proper mascara is a crucial decision. Multiple reasons, including allergies, exhaustion, and outdated contact lenses, can cause sensitive eyes to moisten, get red, and itch incessantly. However, eye makeup is one of the most common causes of eye sensitivity. In order to help you achieve a perfect look, we have already compiled a list of the 10 best waterproof mascaras that are safe for sensitive eyes. Read on for our recommendations for the best mascaras for sensitive eyes, and get ready to swipe without worrying about smudging, clumping, flaking, or, of course, irritated eyes.
Table of contents
- Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
- 10 Best Waterproof Mascara for Sensitive Eyes: Clinique, COVERGIRL, Drama Llama, Essence cosmetics, L'Oreal Paris, La Roche-Posay, Maybelline New York, Neutrogena & WANDER BEAUTY
- Comparison Table: Best Waterproof Mascara for Sensitive Eyes
- Recommendation to read
- WANDER BEAUTY Mile High Club Black Mascara: Intensely saturates lashes
- Clinique High Impact Waterproof Mascara: Instant volume and length
- COVERGIRL Lash Blast Volume Mascara: Mega volume in an instant
- Essence cosmetics Lash Effect Mascara: Lasts all day
- Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara: Advanced thickening formula
- Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara: Safe for sensitive eyes
- L'Oreal Paris Age Perfect Lash Magnifying Mascara: Volumizing formula
- COVERGIRL Professional Curved Brush Mascara: Lengthen & define lashes without flaking
- La Roche-Posay Toleriane Extension Mascara: Visibly longer lashes
- Drama Llama Waterproof Mascara: Enhance long & thicker lashes
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Some matters to discuss
How to choose a waterproof mascara for sensitive eyes?
Hypoallergenic mascara is your primary alternative if you have an allergy. Typically, the hypoallergenic label will be prominently displayed on the container. Even if you are not allergic, choosing a hypoallergenic mascara for sensitive eyes is typically a smart idea because it has been properly evaluated by a dermatologist and will not include any potentially irritating ingredients.
What are mascara's ingredients that is safe for my sensitive eyes?
Choose one that has nourishing elements and will keep your lashes hydrated and flexible. Mineral mascaras, as well as Vitamin E and Aloe Vera, are good choices. It shouldn't get hard and flaky while you're wearing it.
What type of mascara that is safe for my sensitive eyes?
Choose a mild mascara that won't clog your lashes or make them seem clumpy or thick. Although it may seem simple, applying a thick, heavy cream to the eyes is more likely to irritate them, so go for a light formula.
What ingredient in mascara that is not recommended for sensitive eyes?
Only a few reports in the scientific literature talk about allergic contact reactions to mascara or to its ingredients. These ingredients are quaternion-22, shellac, colophony, p-phenylenediamine, yellow carnauba wax, ethylene, black and yellow iron oxides, and nickel.
10 Reviews: Best Waterproof Mascara for Sensitive Eyes (May 2022)
Mile High ClubTM Volume and Length Mascara by WANDER BEAUTY lengthens and lifts lashes. They'll make you appear virtually sky-high. What's the best part? You may only require a few swipes of this natural mascara solution, which contains moisturizing castor seed oil, lengthening trehalose, and conditioning peach leaf extract. Thus, t his waterproof mascara is ideal for sensitive eyes.
"I’m always in a hurry putting on makeup. This mascara is awesome! Doesn’t clump, goes on fast with a few swipes on lashes, and washes off so easily! Best of all it doesn’t smudge or leave black marks under the eyes! I LOVE LOVE LOVE it!!"
by Alfredo R.
|BENEFITS||Lengthening, thickening, etc|
CLINIQUE High ImpactTM Waterproof Mascara was created with you in mind. This mascara is fragrance-free, paraben-free, and ophthalmologist-approved for sensitive eyes. It adds apparent volume and impressive length without flaking, clumping, or smudging throughout the day. It is also waterproof, meaning it can tolerate almost any liquid (besides a good makeup remover, of course). If you are looking for a waterproof mascara that is suitable for sensitive eyes, this one is worth a try.
"This product goes on nice and smooth. It’s not clumpy and doesn’t flake off into your eyes!! I’ve been searching for this for 30 years I’m so happy!!"
by Susan Moore
Looking for a waterproof mascara for sensitive eyes? This Covergirl mascara is good for you because it is hypoallergenic. The product also achieved near-perfect grades in water-resistance testing, showing no smearing, smudging, or running after testers doused their faces 10 times with warm water. Thus, mascara will remain intact even if tears are shed. Additionally, this mascara is available in four distinct hues, allowing you to select your level of audacity.
"This mascara works well and doesn't irritate my eyes."
by Kelli Snow
The Essence Mascara provides you an artificial lash effect that lasts all day. Apply one coat for defined volume right away, or two coats for a more voluminous, dramatic effect. Do you have sensitive eyes? Don't be worried! PETA has validated and recognized this essence cosmetics mascara as a cruelty-free brand. This mascara also has a distinctive fiber brush that sculpts individual lashes for definition and volume without clumps or globs.
"I have purchased this mascara many times. I have even gotten my daughter hooked on it. Great product and great price."
|VOLUME||n / a|
Maybelline's Full 'N Soft Mascara gives lashes a full, healthy appearance without being brittle. With a Quick Dissolve System that allows for quick mascara removal, the unique formula avoids lash loss. Without clumps or globs, the revolutionary thickening formula with Vitamin E softens and nourishes lashes. Furthermore, this mascara is enriched with Vitamin E, and its sophisticated thickening technique delivers silky-soft lashes that are full and healthy-looking. Hence, this mascara is suitable for persons with sensitive eyes.
"This is the best mascara, it keeps your lashes soft not stiff or flaky, it’s really waterproof, so I use a waterproof eye makeup remover, comes off easily. I have sensitive eyes and this mascara has never irritated my eyes like some other brands or formulas."
by aunt Peela
|BENEFITS||Full healthy-looking lashes|
Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara helps to expand eyelashes to their utmost potential. Formulated with antioxidant vitamin E, rice protein, and olive oil, this mascara nourishes and strengthens for lashes that seem up to 100% longer, without clumping, smudging, or flaking. Importantly, this dermatologist- and ophthalmologist-tested brand is safe and mild for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers as part of a daily makeup routine.
"This is my go to for my sensitive eyes. The price has DOUBLED! Ridiculous!"
by G. Reuss
|BENEFITS||Look 100% longer|
The L'Oreal Paris Magnifying Mascara is made for mature lashes. It gives lashes instant volume and care, and it is made with conditioning serum and jojoba oil to make lashes soft and defined. Also, this mascara is gentle enough for people with sensitive eyes. Its easy-to-remove formula is strong enough to make lashes soft and full right away, and its ultra-gentle brush makes it easy to apply.
"This is my favorite “drugstore” mascara. I get so much length and volume, not to mention healthy lashes using this mascara. I love that it is not clumpy at all"
COVERGIRL Professional All-in-One Curved Brush Mascara helps you achieve professional-looking lashes. This 3-in-1 mascara volumizes, lengthens, and defines your lashes without flaking or smearing, giving you stunning lashes that last all day. CoverGirl's formulation for sensitive eyes is also hypoallergenic and appropriate for contact lens users. The mascara has a clump-resistant formula that offers lashes a clean, defined look.
"I have used this mascara for years and still like it. It's a good value and makes lashes thicker. My only complaint is that if my eyes start to water in wind and cold, it smears and I have to reapply."
by Polar Bear
|BENEFITS||Defining, volumizing, lengthening|
The La Roche-Posay Toleriane Extension Lengthening Mascara is a hypoallergenic mascara that was created with sensitive eyes in mind. It lengthens and volumizes lashes by separating individual lashes. This mascara formula has also been allergy-tested and is acceptable for contact lens users. In the Lab's splash test, which involved strong repetitive exposure to warm water, it received great marks for not running or smearing. Polymer is used in the formulation to define and smooth the lashes.
"It goes on really nicely and makes my eyelashes super long! My eyes do still burn (only sometimes) but overall it has done better than any other mascara I’ve found. I would buy it again."
|BENEFITS||Visibly longer lashes|
The Drama Llama waterproof mascara is one of the best mascaras for sensitive eyes since it's devoid of GMOs, cruelty, preservatives, or gluten, and is manufactured from high-quality vegan ingredients. Moreover, this mascara is long-lasting, does not smudge, and makes your natural lashes appear longer and thicker. Secondly, this mascara comes in a little size that is convenient to bring with you wherever you go!
"This mascara is amazing! Long-wearing no smudge and made my natural lashes look so much longer and thicker! Definitely a great product. Going to buy a couple more for stocking stuffers."
by Tiffany B.
|BENEFITS||No smudge, longer & thicker lashes|
When shopping for the perfect mascara for sensitive eyes, look for words like hypoallergenic, allergy-tested, or ophthalmologist- or ophthalmologically-tested on the packaging. Hypoallergenic means that the brand has tried to leave out possible allergens that can cause reactions in some people. Furthermore, the Drama Llama Waterproof Mascara is the best mascara we've found for eyes that are sensitive. It is free of GMOs, animal testing, preservatives, and gluten.