10 Reviews: Best Toasters for Even Toasting (Sep 2023)

You may rely on the KRUPS KH734D Breakfast Set 4-Slot Toaster black and stainless steel model to toast rye bread to a darker brown and white bread to a delicate golden tone. It’s also perfect for entertaining because it can toast up to four pieces at once and keep toasting slices one after another to the same level of doneness without scorching them by the second or even third batch.

"Wanted a quality toaster that I could use for toast, bagels, muffins. Love this one and the settings allow for all those. It looks good as well."

by Shelly

Italian brand SMEG is known for its retro-inspired kitchen appliances, even the box design will have you smitten. Furthermore, this toaster is more than just aesthetically pleasing. Toasted consistently across all settings, the buttons felt high-end. Reheat, thaw, and make a bagel are all options, and it was simple to clean. Thus, it’s perfect for people who are particular about how their kitchen looks and the colors they use.

"I love mine .... 5 years old and zero issues .❤️😎"

by Tech User

Everything about this Hamilton Beach 2-Slice Toaster is straightforward, from its absence of unnecessary packaging to its performance. This type is capable of toasting bagels and waffles consistently and evenly on all settings. The instruction leaflet, as opposed to the booklet, is the appropriate reading material for those who are afraid of reading instructions, and its clear and straightforward appearance fits any countertop design. It’s also a breeze to keep clean, making it a great buy.

"Solid toaster, cheap and still works great after 7 years of regular use."

by afizzo

Lifting it out of the package, you can immediately tell how high-quality it is. The machine’s sturdy build and elegant appearance let you know you can rely on it. Starting toasting by pushing an on/off button is more natural and the browning adjustment slide with its 12 levels allows you to fine-tune your toast. Impatient individuals will appreciate the “Lift & Look” and “A Bit More” buttons, which serve to turn up the heat a notch.

"Toaster performs exactly as advertised……perfect toast!"

by Bobi2416

With the Black + Decker 2-Slice Toaster, it’s possible to have a high-quality toaster without shelling out an arm and leg. This model can toast bagels, large homemade slices of bread, and English muffins, which is great if you eat bread for breakfast on a regular basis. Dorms, kitchens with limited counter space, and those on a tight budget may appreciate its inexpensive cost and modest countertop footprint. In either red or black, it can be yours!

"I love this toaster. It is easy to use and allows for most sizes of bread"

by Linda Fontenot

Make a place on your counter for the stainless steel Cuisinart Bakery Artisan Toaster if your kitchen is always stocked with an unsliced loaf of sourdough. Oversize pieces from round loaves can be toasted in two long slots, or four regular-sized pieces of bread can be toasted simultaneously. This model’s controls are really readable. Therefore, the product includes a crumb tray that can be removed.

"So far I’m happy with my new toaster. I like the defrost feature. I keep English muffins in the freezer and it’s great to defrost before toasting them."

by Jean

If you’re looking for an all-in-one toaster that can handle a variety of bread, this one is for you. It has a memory button so that you can remember exactly how you like your bread toasted the next time. Our favorite feature was the LCD display, which shows you how long you have to wait before the toaster preheats.  Utilizing this feature, you can control how long it takes to brown one slice of bread to your preferred level of crispiness.

"Does work very well! Toast is even on both sides. . Made well ! Recommend 5 stars !"

by Frank

The Cuisinart 2-Slice Compact Toaster is your best option if you don’t want to give up a lot of counter space or live in a home or dorm with a small kitchen. It measures only 6.5″ x 11″ x 7″. It consistently toasts bread to golden brown doneness, and the options (bagel, defrost, and reheat) are simple to read and select. Additionally, the slots on the Cuisinart are large enough to fit thick bagels.

"This toaster is compact and has multiple settings. It toasts the bread nice and evenly."

by Silver49

Controls for this smart toaster can be accessed via a touchscreen tablet. You have three options to choose from each time you press the screen: Whatever it is you’re toasting (baked goods like bread or bagels and pastries like English muffins and waffles) as well as whether it’s fresh, frozen, or going to be reheated should all be considered along with the degree of brownness (seven total). Moreover, to avoid getting cooked, the toast automatically lowers and raises itself. 

"I love everything about it its beautiful and it works excellent 👍"

by ray flippins

A great way to start the day is with a cup of Buydeem. Toasting bread, bagels, and English muffins have never been easier thanks to the two sides, 7 shade settings, and bread, bagel, and English muffin modes. In the actual bagel mode, the bagel is heated on all sides at first, and subsequently, only the sliced sides are toasted. You will find your bread toasted evenly and enjoy your toast deliciously. 

"It is so beautiful and works perfect."

by Lori Pennell