10 Reviews: Best Toasters for English Muffins (Jun 2023)

The Cuisinart CPT-180P1 is a good choice if you want a 2-in-1 toaster. It has four toasting slots that are the 1.5-inch in diameter and large enough just to fit English muffins. When the toast is done, the toaster’s carriage rises. The toaster’s high-lift lever may help you remove little pieces of food from the appliance. Use the thaw option to defrost and toast frozen English muffins. It’s possible that this will take a little longer than usual.

"Liked so far. No problems. Would recommend it."

by Dennis Baierl

Toasting bread with the Cuisinart CPT-122 2-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster results in some of the finest and most evenly browned bread that can be achieved with a toaster. Cuisinart blenders have a wide variety of settings, and simple controls, and stay cold to the touch even after numerous batches have been processed through them. Thus, this toaster will allow you to produce the most delicious English muffins you’ve ever had.

"This is a very good quality and good looking toaster. Toast, English muffins, and bagels all turn out great. No complaints!"

by MMG

The Cuisinart Touch to Toast Leverless toaster is a good choice if you want the convenience of an automatic toaster. Toasting is as simple as pressing the button and watching your food fall into the chamber. Having two control panels gives you the option of creating several shades of English muffins at the same time, which is convenient. You can choose from seven different shade options. To your advantage, you have the option of digitally adjusting the thickness.

"This product works very well and toasts everything evenly."

by Smooth

This toaster is straightforward but incredibly efficient. The conventional two-slot toaster design is still present even if it has undergone some significant changes. This toaster might be for you if you want an excellent one for yourself but nothing too “overkill.” You have the opportunity to make excellent English muffins for your delicacies with this Amazon Basics 2 Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster.

"I like the setting options. They actually work! Toaster is a perfect small great item to have. Doesn’t take up a lot of counter space."

by Eagle145

If you are looking for a toaster that doesn’t require you to fiddle with a multitude of settings, knobs, and buttons, the Hamilton Beach Cool Wall 2 might be the perfect option for you. Moreover, it is a toaster, and it toasts whatever you place in it in the most basic way possible it could. Although it is not an excessively huge container, it is perfectly capable of holding English muffins and bagels.

"This toaster is very lightweight. The red is very cute. Works fine. Good value for the price."

by Beatles65

The KRUPS KH734D is a countertop toaster for English muffins that looks decent and performs really well. It has two separate control panels for each side. This allows you to toast two to four English muffins at the same time in a variety of colors. Astonishingly, the four slots on this toaster are spacious and self-centering. Your morning toast routine will be seamless thanks to the toaster’s four distinct buttons. 

"Wanted a quality toaster that I could use for toast, bagels, muffins. Love this one and the settings allow for all those. It looks good as well."

by Shelly

For English muffin toasting, the Oster 2-Slice toaster saves a lot of space. It’ll fit in a little corner of your counter because it’s only 11.7 x 6.9 x 7.3 inches wide. Despite its diminutive stature, it packs a powerful punch. English muffins will always be perfectly toasted thanks to the Advanced Toasting Technology and the auto-adjusting bread guides it includes. Only two spaces are available because of the modest size. Nonetheless, these two slots are big enough to fit English muffins’ thicker sides.

"Very nice toaster. Looks good and does even toasting"

by Mike

Designed for a long day at the office, this Hamilton Beach Slice Toaster With Keep Warm Settings toaster is ideal. Unique features like “stay warm” are meant to meet the needs of an entrepreneur’s fast-paced lifestyle. Put the “keep warm” setting on your car’s thermostat if you have to be at work in 10 minutes or less. By toasting your English muffins in the toaster, you can keep them warm and ready to consume throughout the day.

"Love the retractable cord. A+"

by Andrew A.

You’re going to need some extra-wide slots to accommodate your thick English muffins. The Wolf Gourmet’s 2-Slice Extra-Wide Slot will do the trick for your needs. The self-centering slots ensure that whatever you put in will be uniformly browned and raised out of the toaster when the toasting cycle is done. Therefore, the keep warm mode allows you to reheat your English muffins without further browning. 

"This is a class item for your kitchen. The name Wolf means an excellent product."

by Johnny D.

The dual-side toaster from Buydeem is designed to bring delight to your household with no more damaged or wasted toast thanks to its 7 shade settings and distinctive bread, bagel, and English muffin modes. After preheating both sides of a bagel, only the cut edges are toasted in true bagel mode. Within three minutes, the bread piece mode toasts the evening. Last but not least, the English Muffin mode gently warms both sides of the muffin in just the right amount of time. 

"Love the look of this toaster. Great value and quality. Easy to use. Would recommend."

by Alison