10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec 2021)

These rich, natural-but-better hair color will make you look even more fabulous!

W. Auliasari By W. Auliasari · updated on · price $6.95 - $31.00 · 10 views

We hope you love the shops and products we recommend! Just so you know, our site may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Oh, and FYI — prices are accurate and products in stock as of time of publication.

Comparison Table

Let's jump to the specs!
Product Image
1
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): Fade-resistant results
Clairol Professional
2
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): Hiding annoying grays
Revlon
3
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): Demi-permanent pick
Clairol
4
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): For dark hair
SoftSheen-Carson
5
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): Protects against breakage
Creme of Nature
6
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): For sensitive scalps
Schwarzkopf
7
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): Good-for-you naturals
Shea Moisture
8
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): High-quality cream base
Good Dye Young
9
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): 100% gray coverage
Madison Reed
10
10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec  2021): Prolong your hair color
maria nila
Product Name Texture and Tones Total Color Natural Instincts Dark and Lovely Pure Honey Simply Color Color Crème Gravedigger Pescara Black - 2NNA Colour Refresh
Features Fade-resistant results Hiding annoying grays Demi-permanent pick For dark hair Protects against breakage For sensitive scalps Good-for-you naturals High-quality cream base 100% gray coverage Prolong your hair color
Hair Type All All All All All All All All All Blonde
Format Permanent Permanent Demi-permanent​ Permanent Semi-permanent​ Permanent Permanent Semi-permanent​ n/a Non-permanent
Color 14 options 16 options 5 options Spicy Red Fire Red 6 options 8 options Gravedigger Blackest Black Dusty Pink
Capacity 1 application 1 application 1 application 1 application 1 application 1 application 1 application 1 application n/a n/a
price $6.95 $6.98 $7.99 $8.67 $8.99 $9.97 $9.99 $18.00 $22.00 $31.00
Buy at view reviews on Clairol Professional view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on Revlon view reviews on Walmart view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on Clairol view reviews on Ulta view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on SoftSheen-Carson view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on Creme Of Nature view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on Schwarzkopf view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on Shea Moisture view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on Good Dye Young view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on Madison Reed view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay view reviews on maria nila view reviews on Amazon view reviews on eBay

It’s quite hard to get a completely chemical-free hair dye. Not to mention that phrases like ‘natural’ and ‘organic’ aren’t regulated, so such promises should be taken with a grain of salt. Thus, if you’re searching for more natural hair color, whether you’re pregnant, vegan, or just want to be a more aware consumer, your best chance is to do some ingredient research and know which ones to avoid. Sounds too overwhelming? That’s fine! We’ve done the legwork and included ten of our best hair dyes for natural hair below.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Just in case you wonder...

Does dye damage natural hair?

Unfortunately, this is true. However, this does not have to be done all at once. It normally requires frequent exposure to cause severe damage, particularly if you're going from dark hair to, say, platinum blonde. Even though your hair is stiff, if you color it properly, your coils and curls should be OK.

Is it possible to color my hair without bleaching it?

Dying your hair any darker than it is does not need bleaching, thus the lighter your natural hair color or the shade you begin with, the more alternatives you have. If you want to experiment with vibrant colors, you almost always need to lighten your hair first for the best color effect.

How to make hair color last longer?

1. Do not shampoo immediately.
2. Use hair products designed for colored hair.
3. Avoid using hot water.
4. Invest in hair masks and other conditioning treatments for your hair.
5. Avoid using heat styling on your hair too often.

What is the difference between "semi permanent" and "demi permanent" hair dye?

The main difference between semi-permanent and demi-permanent hair color is how long it lasts after repeated washings and exposure to sunshine. Demi-permanent hair color contains no ammonia and is blended with a low-volume developer, so it washes out after 24 to 28 shampoos. Meanwhile, semi-permanent hair color is a deposit-only, temporary hair color that lasts 3 to 6 washes.

10 Reviews: Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair (Dec 2021)

Here are the best hair dye for natural hair
Clairol Professional Texture and Tones - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: Fade-resistant results
https://www.amazon.com/

1.
Clairol Professional
Texture and Tones

Fade-resistant results

price from
$6.95
Our Opinion:

The exquisite Texture & Tones Permanent Hair Color and Conditioning System are designed to deliver fade-resistant results. To obtain the right appearance and up to 100% gray coverage, choose from a broad choice of colors including red, brown, and blonde. Natural protein and jojoba are included in the luscious, moisture-rich, conditioning, and anti-fade formula for long-lasting color and shine.

Promising Review:

This is the first hair dye I’ve tried on my natural hair and it’s amazing! It usually takes two boxes for each process because I have a lot of hair, but the color always comes out nicely & it’s better for the summer days where the color pops in the sun! I’d definitely recommend those with curly hair to use this dye.

by Kyla

Hair Type All
Format Permanent
Color 14 options
Capacity 1 application
Revlon  Total Color - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: Hiding annoying grays
https://www.walmart.com/

2.
Revlon
Total Color

Hiding annoying grays

price from
$6.98
Our Opinion:

This is an excellent option for folks who don't want to spend a lot of money on boxed dye. The cream formula is not only affordable, but it is also free of a slew of potentially harmful substances, such as ammonia, parabens, sulfates, silicones, and phthalates. The cream formula is non-dripping, and the permanent color lasts up to six weeks while totally hiding any annoying grays. Extra marks include a botanical-based conditioning gloss.

Promising Review:

[...] I saw this one and decided to give it a try. So glad I did! I can dye my hair again. I use dark brown which is my natural color. This does not last as long as other dyes, but I make it last longer by not washing my hair each day, which is better for my hair anyway. [...]

by ftworthmomof4

Hair Type All
Format Permanent
Color 16 options
Capacity 1 application
Clairol Natural Instincts - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: Demi-permanent pick
https://www.ulta.com/

3.
Clairol
Natural Instincts

Demi-permanent pick

price from
$7.99
Our Opinion:

This low-cost item is ultra-gentle and ammonia-free, and it's formulated with 80 percent naturally derived ingredients like coconut and aloe vera, to name a few. Because it's a demi-permanent color (it should last up to 28 washes), it's perfect for blending in small amounts of gray or boosting your original shade and gloss rather than a complete color change. Nonetheless, there are over 35 shades to pick from, including a wide range of blonde, brown, black, and red tones.

Promising Review:

This color stays true and doesn't damage my hair and the color is long lasting and doesn't fade away

by Honey

Hair Type All
Format Demi-permanent​
Color 5 options
Capacity 1 application
SoftSheen-Carson Dark and Lovely - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: For dark hair
https://www.amazon.com/

4.
SoftSheen-Carson
Dark and Lovely

For dark hair

price from
$8.67
Our Opinion:

SoftSheen-Carson Dark and Lovely is perfect for those with dark hair. With this extremely pigmented dye, you can add noticeable, long-lasting, fade-resistant color to your natural hair. To offer high-impact shine and ultra-smoothness, the nourishing drip-free product contains an anti-drying gel blended with moisturizing olive oil. This hair dye range delivers properly matched color dyes to give rich, visible high reflect color that works on dark hair.

Promising Review:

My complexion in light brown and I have short natural black hair, greying around the temples and the front edge. This color completely covered my gray and the shade of red is very becoming. I have had so many compliments...(even from my granddaughter who is 14 and very conservative.) [...]

by Marie Gordon

Hair Type All
Format Permanent
Color Spicy Red
Capacity 1 application
Creme of Nature Pure Honey - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: Protects against breakage
https://www.amazon.com/

5.
Creme of Nature
Pure Honey

Protects against breakage

price from
$8.99
Our Opinion:

With a moisturizing and conditioning formula enhanced with Pure Honey, Creme of Nature Hydrating Color Boost nourishes each strand as it colors. This non-drying solution protects against breakage while encouraging healthy-looking, gleaming hair. This item, which is enriched with genuine honey, helps to guard against breaking. With this new semi-permanent, moisturizing color boost, you can get a bright, brilliant color in only 15 minutes.

Hair Type All
Format Semi-permanent​
Color Fire Red
Capacity 1 application
Schwarzkopf Simply Color - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: For sensitive scalps
https://www.amazon.com/

6.
Schwarzkopf
Simply Color

For sensitive scalps

price from
$9.97
Our Opinion:

This gentle hair color contains botanical oat milk, soy protein, and argan oil. This permanent color is offered in ten shades, nine of which are aimed toward a variety of brown and black tones. It's free of ammonia, alcohol, and silicones, and it's also dermatologist-tested, which is great for those with sensitive scalps. Nonetheless, the color is full-on permanent, incredibly vivid, and claims to cover 100 percent of gray hair, which is always a plus, particularly on darker hair.

Promising Review:

I used Intense Espresso to get back to my natural hair color. I didn’t apply it perfectly, so you can still see a little of the previous color. Overall, I love the color and it didn’t have that awful ammonia smell that other box dyes do.

by Amazon Customer

Hair Type All
Format Permanent
Color 6 options
Capacity 1 application
Shea Moisture Color Crème - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: Good-for-you naturals
https://www.amazon.com/

7.
Shea Moisture
Color Crème

Good-for-you naturals

price from
$9.99
Our Opinion:

SheaMoisture Color Crème is the next step in providing healthier hair solutions. It combines natural and certified organic healing components with risk-free science. You'll obtain an effective system with a colorful color palette by using the signature certified organic Shea Butter and blending it with additional good-for-you naturals. This color care contains nutritious elements that assist limit damage while providing great moisture and shine.

Promising Review:

Very good results. My hair matches the soft black perfectly. Looks natural. Great coverage on my gray hairs (sparse hairs). Great shine. I now buy the conditioner that comes with this product

by Enya Rentas-Sherman

Hair Type All
Format Permanent
Color 8 options
Capacity 1 application
Good Dye Young Gravedigger - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: High-quality cream base
https://gooddyeyoung.com/

8.
Good Dye Young
Gravedigger

High-quality cream base

price from
$18.00
Our Opinion:

This semi-permanent hair color does not harm the hair and is really conditioning. GDY's formula blends a high-quality cream base, similar to a hair mask, with the advantages of essential oils. The color is applied to the top of the hair shaft and acts as a stain, fading away over time when you wash your hair. The color can persist for up to 4-6 weeks. To keep color vivid for longer, we suggest applying color-protecting hair care.

Promising Review:

The colors are always amazing, they work so well and smell so good. The semipermanents are always my go to and will be my only go to.

by Molly S.

Hair Type All
Format Semi-permanent​
Color Gravedigger
Capacity 1 application
Madison Reed Pescara Black - 2NNA - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: 100% gray coverage
https://www.madison-reed.com/

9.
Madison Reed
Pescara Black - 2NNA

100% gray coverage

price from
$22.00
Our Opinion:

This Smart 8-Free permanent hair color has no harmful ingredients and contains hair-loving nutrients such as keratin, argan oil, and ginseng root. It provides 100% gray coverage and leaves hair feeling healthy, conditioned, and shining. If you're attempting color for the first time, don't be afraid; experienced, licensed hair colorists are standing by to review your photos and give help through phone, text, and chat.

Promising Review:

[...] The color is very inky and gorgeous. Love the barrier cream and wipes too! Worth every penny, I got two tubes as my hair is to the middle of my back. No ammonia burning of the eyes, beyond happy and impressed! Thank you thank you !!

by Erin W.

Hair Type All
Format n/a
Color Blackest Black
Capacity n/a
maria nila Colour Refresh - Best Hair Dye for Natural Hair: Prolong your hair color
https://marianila.com/

10.
maria nila
Colour Refresh

Prolong your hair color

price from
$31.00
Our Opinion:

Although it is not a true hair dye, it can be used to extend the life of your existing hair color. A nourishing color bomb masque with non-permanent color pigments that will instantly refresh your hair. The masque hydrates and smoothes the hair, leaving it velvety smooth and lustrous. Every Colour Refresh comes with a pair of gloves. Colour Refresh is ideal for usage in between color sessions at the salon or for special occasions.

Hair Type Blonde
Format Non-permanent
Color Dusty Pink
Capacity n/a

A part of Rank Media Teknologi PT

We may earn a commission for purchases made through our links.

©2021 SoPicky by Rank M.T. PT. All rights reserved.